BLOG
Understanding Your Right to Remain Silent in Iowa
Robert Stahle • June 14, 2021
You more than likely have heard a police officer utter, “you have the right to remain silent” in countless television shows and movies, but do you know what exactly it means in a legal context? Believe it or not, the arrest scenes in Hollywood movies largely stay true to the actual legal process and procedures. In the famous case of Miranda v. Arizona , the judge ruled that law enforcement officers advise arrested suspects of certain rights, including the option of remaining silent and saying nothing.
Here at Fitch & Stahle Law Office, our auto accident lawyer is here to stand by your side and protect your constitutional rights when you are arrested. Many police officers fail to uphold the law when making an arrest, and failure to inform suspects of their so-called Miranda rights is a common defense in court. Here is what you need to know about your right to remain silent, presented by our drunk driving lawyer.
When Must the Police Inform You of Your Rights?
Police are legally obligated to inform suspects of their rights before they interrogate them in custody. Interrogation doesn’t only include questioning but also any words or actions that police officers should know are reasonably linked to elicit an incriminating response. The main point of the Miranda warning is that the prosecution cannot use a suspect’s silence as evidence of guilt in court.
However, police officers are not technically required to inform suspects of their right to remain silent when they are not technically in custody. Thus, it is relatively common for police to question suspects after letting them know they are not under arrest and are free to leave. By using this method, police officers do not have to provide the Miranda warning.
2013 Supreme Court Decision
In 2013, there was a closely contested U.S. Supreme Court decision that held that prosecutors can, under some circumstances, point to an out-of-custody suspect’s silence in response to police questioning as evidence of guilt. According to this case, our drug lawyer will tell you that the prosecution can common on the silence of a suspect who:
- Is out of police custody (and not Mirandized)
- Voluntarily submits to police questioning
- Stays silent without expressly invoking his Fifth Amendment rights
How to Invoke the Right to Remain Silent
The 2013 Supreme Court decision raises new questions, such as whether it is reasonable to place the brunt of asserting constitutional rights on normal people. More practically, people are now asking what exactly an out-of-custody person must say to a police officer to effectively invoke their right to silence. Previous court decisions have indicated that people should be clear that they are invoking their Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination.
Sioux City Auto Accident Lawyer
Whether you have been arrested for drunk driving, drugs, or an automobile accident, our Sioux City attorneys are here to protect your rights. We are dedicated to providing residents of the Siouxland area with professional legal advice for a range of needs, and our attorneys are licensed to practice in both Iowa and Nebraska.
Contact us at 402-494-3012.
If you’ve recently been in a car accident, you're likely dealing with more than just vehicle damage. The aftermath of an auto collision can be overwhelming—medical bills, missed work, emotional stress, and constant calls from insurance adjusters. During this time, it’s easy to feel like you’re navigating a maze alone. That’s where a qualified car accident attorney can make a significant difference. At Fitch & Stahle Law Firm, we’re here to explain why hiring an experienced lawyer is one of the most important steps you can take to protect your rights and secure the compensation you deserve. 1. Understanding the Legal Complexity of Car Accidents Car accident claims are rarely as simple as they seem. While the facts may appear straightforward—one car hit another—multiple factors like weather conditions, traffic laws, and vehicle defects can complicate liability. Add in varying state laws, such as comparative negligence rules in Iowa and Nebraska, and the process becomes even more complex. An experienced attorney from Fitch & Stahle understands these legal intricacies. We work to gather evidence, assess liability, and build a strong case that represents your best interests. 2. Insurance Companies Are Not On Your Side After an accident, one of the first calls you'll get is from the insurance company. They may sound helpful, but it’s important to remember they’re looking out for their own bottom line—not yours. Insurance adjusters are trained to minimize payouts. They might offer you a quick settlement, ask misleading questions, or try to get you to admit fault. When you hire an attorney, you shift the balance of power. At Fitch & Stahle, we handle all communication with insurance companies so you don’t have to. We know how to counter lowball offers and negotiate settlements that reflect the full extent of your injuries and losses. 3. Calculating the True Value of Your Claim Many accident victims underestimate the value of their claim, especially when pressured to accept early settlement offers. A fair settlement should cover more than just your car repairs and immediate medical bills. You may be entitled to compensation for: Current and future medical expenses Lost wages and loss of earning capacity Pain and suffering Emotional distress Property damage Permanent disability or disfigurement Our legal team takes a comprehensive approach when calculating your damages. We collaborate with medical professionals, vocational experts, and economists to ensure every aspect of your claim is properly valued. 4. Proving Liability Requires Evidence To receive compensation, you must prove that another party was at fault—and that requires solid evidence. Unfortunately, important documentation can disappear quickly after a crash. Witnesses forget details, accident scenes get cleaned up, and insurance companies may fail to preserve relevant records. At Fitch & Stahle, we act quickly to secure the evidence you need. Our legal team gathers police reports, photographs, surveillance footage, medical records, and witness statements. In complex cases, we may also bring in accident reconstruction specialists to strengthen your claim. 5. Meeting Deadlines and Legal Requirements Every state has a statute of limitations that limits how long you have to file a personal injury lawsuit after a car accident. In Iowa, for example, you typically have two years from the date of the accident to file a claim. Missing this deadline could mean losing your right to compensation altogether. Beyond the statute of limitations, there are other procedural requirements, such as notifying your insurance company or filing certain documents in a specific format. One small mistake could delay or derail your case. When you work with Fitch & Stahle, we ensure every deadline is met and every form is filed correctly, giving your case the best chance at success. 6. You’ll Be Better Prepared if the Case Goes to Court While many car accident cases settle out of court, some do proceed to trial—especially when fault is disputed or damages are significant. Having a lawyer from the beginning means you're prepared for anything. Our attorneys are experienced litigators who are not afraid to take your case to court if that’s what it takes to get justice. We prepare every case as if it will go to trial, which puts us in a stronger negotiating position from day one. 7. Peace of Mind While You Focus on Recovery One of the most overlooked benefits of hiring an attorney is the peace of mind it brings. After an accident, your focus should be on healing—not haggling with insurance companies or navigating complex legal systems. When you hire Fitch & Stahle, we take on the legal burden so you can focus on your recovery. From handling paperwork and phone calls to negotiating settlements and representing you in court, we’ll be your advocate every step of the way. Real Clients. Real Results. At Fitch & Stahle Law Firm, we’ve represented countless car accident victims throughout Sioux City and the surrounding communities. Our proven track record of successful settlements and verdicts speaks to the dedication and skill of our legal team. “After my accident, I didn’t know where to start. Fitch & Stahle took care of everything and made sure I got the compensation I needed to get back on my feet.” – Former Client Contact Fitch & Stahle Law Firm Today The decisions you make after a car accident can impact your life for years to come. Don’t go through it alone. If you’ve been injured in a car accident in Sioux City or anywhere in the tri-state area, contact Fitch & Stahle Law Firm today for a free consultation. We’ll evaluate your case, answer your questions, and help you understand your legal options—at no cost to you unless we win. Fitch & Stahle Law Firm — Fighting for Siouxland’s Injured Since Day One. 📞 Call today or visit fitch-stahlelaw.com to schedule your free consultation.
At Fitch & Stahle Law Firm, we recognize that the aftermath of a car accident is overwhelming. Beyond the physical and emotional stress, navigating the legal process can be confusing. Understanding what to expect and how to proceed can make a significant difference in your case. The Steps of a Car Accident Claim 1. Filing a Police Report: This is essential for documenting the accident and establishing key details. 2. Seeking Medical Attention: Even if you don’t feel injured immediately, a medical examination is crucial. 3. Gathering Evidence: Collect photos, witness statements, and other documentation that can support your claim. 4. Consulting an Attorney: Speaking with an experienced car accident lawyer ensures your rights are protected from the start. 5. Negotiating with Insurance Companies: Your attorney will handle discussions to secure a fair settlement. 6. Filing a Lawsuit if Necessary: If negotiations fail, your lawyer may recommend pursuing legal action in court. Understanding these steps can help you prepare and avoid common pitfalls. Contact Fitch & Stahle today to discuss your case. 2. Understanding Comparative Fault in Car Accidents: How It Affects Your Claim One of the most misunderstood aspects of car accident cases is comparative fault. Many accident victims assume that if they share any blame for the accident, they can’t recover compensation. However, laws vary by state, and even if you are partially at fault, you may still be entitled to damages. How Comparative Fault Works • Pure Comparative Fault: In some states, you can recover damages even if you are 99% at fault, though your compensation will be reduced by your percentage of fault. • Modified Comparative Fault: Many states bar recovery if you are more than 50% or 51% responsible for the accident. • Contributory Negligence: A few states prevent you from receiving any compensation if you are even 1% at fault. How an Attorney Can Help Insurance companies often try to assign more fault to victims to reduce payouts. At Fitch & Stahle, we gather evidence and build strong cases to challenge unfair liability assessments. If comparative fault is a concern in your case, reach out to us for a consultation. 3. The Role of Witnesses in Car Accident Cases Eyewitness testimony can play a crucial role in proving liability and securing compensation in a car accident claim. Many people overlook the importance of witnesses, but their statements can provide unbiased perspectives on what happened. Why Witness Testimony Matters • Clarifies Fault: Witnesses can confirm which driver was negligent. • Supports Your Version of Events: Their statements can strengthen your claim. • Helps Refute False Claims: If the other party tries to shift blame, witnesses can counter their argument. How to Secure Witness Testimony • Get Contact Information: Always collect names, phone numbers, and addresses of potential witnesses. • Ask for a Statement: If possible, have them describe what they saw while it’s fresh in their memory. • Work with Your Attorney: Your lawyer can follow up and ensure their testimony is properly documented. If you’ve been in a car accident, don’t underestimate the power of a strong witness statement. Contact us at Fitch & Stahle to discuss how we can use this evidence to strengthen your case. 4. Understanding Economic vs. Non-Economic Damages in Car Accident Cases After a car accident, victims may be entitled to different types of damages. Understanding the difference between economic and non-economic damages can help you build a comprehensive claim. Economic Damages These damages cover tangible financial losses, including: • Medical bills • Lost wages • Property damage • Rehabilitation costs Non-Economic Damages These damages compensate for intangible losses, such as: • Pain and suffering • Emotional distress • Loss of enjoyment of life • Permanent disfigurement or disability Maximizing Your Compensation Insurance companies often try to downplay non-economic damages. At Fitch & Stahle, we work to ensure our clients receive full compensation for both economic and non-economic losses. Contact us today to learn how we can help. 5. How Weather Conditions Can Impact Car Accident Liability Many drivers assume that bad weather absolves them of responsibility in an accident. However, weather conditions do not eliminate liability—they simply add another layer of complexity to the case. Common Weather-Related Accidents • Rain & Wet Roads: Slippery surfaces increase stopping distances and reduce control. • Snow & Ice: Black ice and snowy roads can lead to loss of control. • Fog & Low Visibility: Limited visibility increases the risk of collisions. Determining Fault in Weather-Related Accidents While poor weather can contribute to an accident, drivers are still expected to adjust their behavior accordingly. Liability may depend on whether a driver: • Was driving too fast for conditions • Failed to use headlights or windshield wipers properly • Followed another vehicle too closely If you were in a weather-related accident, having an attorney review your case can help determine fault and ensure you receive fair compensation. Contact Fitch & Stahle for expert legal guidance. 6. The Importance of Seeking Medical Attention After a Car Accident One of the most crucial steps after a car accident is seeking medical attention. Many people delay or avoid medical treatment because they feel fine immediately after the crash. However, some injuries take time to appear, and delaying treatment can negatively impact both your health and your legal case. Common Injuries That May Not Show Symptoms Right Away • Whiplash: Neck pain and stiffness can develop hours or days after an accident. • Concussions: Symptoms like headaches, dizziness, and confusion may be delayed. • Internal Bleeding: Serious internal injuries may not be noticeable at first but can be life-threatening if untreated. • Soft Tissue Injuries: Muscle strains and ligament damage can worsen over time. How Delaying Medical Treatment Affects Your Claim • Insurance Companies May Argue Your Injuries Aren’t Serious: If you wait too long to see a doctor, insurers may claim your injuries aren’t related to the accident. • Gaps in Treatment Can Weaken Your Case: Consistent medical records help establish the severity of your injuries and the necessity of treatment. • Your Recovery May Take Longer: Early diagnosis and treatment can prevent complications and speed up your recovery process. At Fitch & Stahle, we strongly recommend that all accident victims seek medical attention immediately, even if they feel fine. Doing so protects both your health and your legal rights. If you’ve been injured in a car accident, contact us today for expert legal guidance on your next steps. 7. Why You Should Hire a Car Accident Attorney as Soon as Possible Many people hesitate to hire an attorney after a car accident, thinking they can handle their claim alone. However, involving an attorney early can make a significant difference in the outcome of your case. Benefits of Hiring a Car Accident Attorney Quickly • Preserving Evidence: Attorneys can collect crucial evidence before it disappears. • Dealing with Insurance Companies: Insurance adjusters may try to minimize your claim, but an attorney ensures fair negotiations. • Avoiding Mistakes: Legal guidance helps prevent common errors that could weaken your case. • Maximizing Compensation: Lawyers understand how to calculate and pursue the full extent of your damages. If you or a loved one has been injured in a car accident, don’t wait to seek legal help. Contact Fitch & Stahle today to protect your rights and secure the compensation you deserve.